Volume 2, Issue 3, September 2017, Page: 59-81
Six Sigma Hoax: The Way Professionals Deceive Science
Fausto Galetto, Independent Scholar, Buccinasco (Milan), Italy
Received: Feb. 21, 2017;       Accepted: Mar. 27, 2017;       Published: May 5, 2017
DOI: 10.11648/j.ns.20170203.11      View  1731      Downloads  79
Abstract
Statistics is used in Physics (and in Nuclear Science as well): Six Sigma can be useful if properly applied; therefore scientists have to take into account the “correct” ideas. The document shows the ideas of the author to overcome the deep ignorance on Quality as it is found in many books dealing with Statistical Quality Control and Six Sigma. It is evident that there are many types of falseness provided by the “6 SigMONA practitioners”: they rob money from their clients that are not aware of that. When the 6σ BMWists say “A company’s performance is measured by the sigma level of their business processes” they lie: they do not know that, IF they compute s from the company’s data, they know the estimate s (NOT σ) AND s is never equal to σ! The 1st falseness is the statement “variation is the enemy of Quality”. The 2nd falseness is the statement “variability reduction is Quality”. The 3rd falseness is the wide-spread use of the “Normal Distribution”. The 4th falseness is the statement “the number of defectives is 3.4 ppm”. The “6 SigMONA movement” does not deal properly with problem prevention, as on the contrary is done by GIQA. Scientificness is absent in the “6 SigMONA applications” as shown in the authors books.
Keywords
Six Sigma, Scientific Approach, Quality Education, Quality Methods, Rational Manager, Quality Tetralogy, Intellectual Honesty
To cite this article
Fausto Galetto, Six Sigma Hoax: The Way Professionals Deceive Science, Nuclear Science. Vol. 2, No. 3, 2017, pp. 59-81. doi: 10.11648/j.ns.20170203.11
Copyright
Copyright © 2017 Authors retain the copyright of this article.
This article is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Reference
[1]
Deming W. E., 1986, Out of the Crisis, Cambridge University Press.
[2]
Deming W. E., 1997, The new economics for industry, government, education, Cambridge University Press.
[3]
Juran, J., 1988, Quality Control Handbook, 4th ed, McGraw-Hill, New York.
[4]
M. Gell-Mann., 1994, The Quark and the Jaguar: Adventures in the Simple and the Complex, W. Freeman and Company, N. Y.
[5]
Shewhart W. A., 1931, Economic Control of Quality of Manufactured Products, D. Van Nostrand Company.
[6]
Shewhart W. A., 1936, Statistical Method from the Viewpoint of Quality Control, Graduate School, Washington.
[7]
Montgomery D. C., 1996, Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, Wiley & Sons (wrong definition of the term "Quality", and many other drawbacks in wrong applications).
[8]
Montgomery D. C., 2009, 6th edition, Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, Wiley & Sons (wrong).
[9]
Montgomery D. C., 2011, 5th edition, Applied Statistics And Probability For Engineers, Wiley & Sons.
[10]
Montgomery D. C., 2013, 8th edition, Design and Analysis of Experiments, Wiley & Sons.
[11]
Montgomery D. C., editions after 2009 are worse, Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, Wiley & Sons (wrong definition of the term "Quality", and many other drawbacks in wrong applications).
[12]
Cascini E., Sei Sigma per docenti in 14 capitoli, RCE Multimedia 2009.
[13]
Arcidiacono G., et al. Governare i processi per governare l'impresa - Lean Six Sigma, Springer 2014.
[14]
Citti P., La metodologia sei sigma nei servizi, Firenze University Press 2006.
[15]
Pyzdek T., The Six Sigma Handbook A Complete Guide For Green Belts, Black Belts, And Managers At All Levels, McGraw-Hill 2003.
[16]
Munro R., et al., The Certified Six Sigma Green Belt Handbook, American Society for Quality 2015.
[17]
Pande P., et al., The Six Sigma Way_How GE, Motorola, and Other Top Companies are Honing their performance, McGraw-Hill.
[18]
Brue G., Six Sigma for Managers, McGraw-Hill 2005.
[19]
Eckes G., Six Sigma for Everyone- (2003) Managers, Wiley 2003.
[20]
Craig G. et al., Six Sigma for Dummies, Wiley 2012.
[21]
Allen T., Introduction to Engineering Statistics and Six Sigma, Springer 2006.
[22]
PARK S. (1996), Robust Design and Analysis for Quality Engineering, Chapman & Hall, London.
[23]
F. Kutsanedzie, S. Achio, E. Ameko, Basic concepts and applications of experimental design, Science Publishing Group 2015, ISBN:978-1-940366-500.
[24]
Taguchi G., "Product quality evaluation and tolerancing", 30th EOQC Conference, Stockholm 1986.
[25]
Taguchi G., System of Experimental Design, vol.1, ASI (American Supplier Institute) and Unipub Kraus International Publications.
[26]
Taguchi G., System of Experimental Design, vol.2, ASI and Unipub Kraus International Publications.
[27]
Taguchi G., Introduction to quality engineering, Asian Productivity Organization, 1988.
[28]
Taguchi G., Yu-In Wu, Introduction to off-line quality control, Central Japan Quality Control Association, 1979.
[29]
Taguchi S., Byrne D., 1986 The Taguchi Approach to Parameter Design, Best Technical Paper (!?), American Society for Quality Control.
[30]
F. Franceschini, M. Galetto, D. Maisano, L. Mastrogiacomo, B. Pralio, Distributed Large-Scale Dimensional Metrology, New Insights, Springer-Verlag London Limited 2011.
[31]
Franceschini F, Maisano D, Mastrogiacomo L, Pralio B (2010) Ultrasound transducers for largescale metrology: a performance analysis for their use by the MScMS. IEEE Trans Instrum Meas 59 (1):110–121.
[32]
F. Galetto, Nuovi sviluppi nel calcolo dei parametri affidabilistici dei sistemi, LXXIII Riunione annuale AEI, Torino, 1972.
[33]
F. Galetto, Numero dei guasti di un sistema e determinazione di un modello reale atto a rappresentarlo, VIII congr. AICQ, Napoli, 1973.
[34]
F. Galetto, Integrazione Numerica di Equazioni Integrali di Volterra, Facoltà di Matematica, Bologna, 1973.
[35]
F. Galetto, Pitfalls of Bayes Methods, Internat. conf. on Reliability/ Diagnostics, Torino, 1986 .
[36]
F. Galetto, CLARA (Cost and Life Appraisal via Reliability Analysis), 30th EOQC Conference, Stoccolma, 1986.
[37]
F. Galetto, SARA (System Availability and Reliability Analysis), Annual Reliability Symposium, Philadelphia, 1977.
[38]
F. Galetto, CLAUDIA (Cost and Life Analysis via Up and Down time Integral Approach), XXI EOQC Conf., Varna, 1977.
[39]
GALETTO F. (1978), An application of experimental design in the Automotive field, SIA Congress.
[40]
F. Galetto, NORA (a New Outlook on Reliability of Automobiles), XXIII EOQC Conf., Budapest, 1979.
[41]
F. Galetto, New results in reliability analysis, 2nd Int. Conf. on Reliability/ Maintainab., Perros- Guirec, 1980.
[42]
GALETTO F. (1984) Assessment of Product Reliability, World Quality Congress '84, Brighton.
[43]
GALETTO F. (1986) Quality/Reliability: How to get results, EOQC (Automotive Section), Madrid.
[44]
F. Galetto, Are Bayes Methods really better ?, IASTED Int. Conf. on Quality/ Reliability, Paris, 1987.
[45]
GALETTO F. (1987) Quality and Reliability, the Iveco way, Mgt Dev. Review by MCE, Brussels.
[46]
GALETTO F. (1988) Quality and reliability. A must for industry, ISATA, Montecarlo.
[47]
F. Galetto, Comment on: 'New Practical Bayes Estimators for the 2-parameters Weibull distribution, IEEE Transactions on Reliability vol.37, 1988.
[48]
GALETTO F. (1989) Quality of methods for quality is important, EOQC Conference, Vienna.
[49]
GALETTO F. (1990) Basic and managerial concerns on Taguchi Methods, ISATA, Florence.
[50]
F. Galetto, Qualità. Alcuni metodi statistici da Manager, CUSL, 1995.
[51]
F. Galetto, Quality: Management Commitment is not enough, ISATA, Vienna, 1990.
[52]
GALETTO F., LEVI R. (1993) Planned Experiments: key factors for product Quality, 3rd AMST 93, Udine.
[53]
GALETTO F. (1993) DOE. Importanti idee sulla Qualità per i manager, DEINDE, Torino.
[54]
GALETTO F. (1993) Which kind of Quality? Of products, of processes, of Management? 1st AITEM, Ancona.
[55]
Galetto, F., Managerial Issues for Design of Experiments, 4th AMST 96, Udine, 1996.
[56]
Galetto, F., We need Quality of Managers, Quality 97, 6th Intern. Conf., Ostrava, Czeh Republic, 1997.
[57]
Galetto, F., Quality Education on Quality for Future Managers, 1st Conference on TQM for HEI (Higher Education Institutions), Tolone, 1998.
[58]
Galetto, F., GIQA the Golden Integral Quality Approach: from Management of Quality to Quality of Management, Total Quality Management (TQM), Vol. 10, No. 1, 1999.
[59]
Galetto, F., Quality Education and Total Quality Management, 2nd Conf. on TQM for HEI, Verona, 1999.
[60]
Galetto, F., Quality Methods for Design of Experiments, 5th AMST 99, Udine, 1999.
[61]
Galetto, F., Quality Function Deployment, Some Managerial Concerns, AITEM99, Brescia, 1999.
[62]
GALETTO F., GENTILI E. (1999), The need of Quality Methods used for Quality CAPE '99, Durham, UK.
[63]
GALETTO F., GENTILI E. (1999), Quality of the Quality Methods, AITEM 99 Conference, Brescia.
[64]
GALETTO F., GENTILI E. (2000), In search of Quality in QFD and Taguchi methods, CAPE.
[65]
GALETTO F. (2000) Qualità. Alcuni metodi statistici da Manager, CLUT, Torino.
[66]
Galetto, F., Quality Education for Professors teaching Quality to Future Managers, 3rd Conf. on TQM for HEI, Derby, UK, 2000.
[67]
Galetto, F., Statistical Thinking, Customer Satisfaction, Qualità del Servizio e Formazione Universitaria, Conv. SIS, Firenze, 2000.
[68]
Galetto, F., Quality, Bayes Methods and Control Charts, 2nd ICME 2000 Conference, Capri, 2000.
[69]
Galetto, F., Reliability Integral Theory applied to "two machines lines" with failures, 2nd ICME 2000 Conference, Capri, 2000.
[70]
Galetto, F., RELIABILITY PREDICTION DURING DEVELOPMENT, ATA conf., Firenze, 2000.
[71]
Galetto, F., Looking for Quality in "quality books", 4th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Mons, Belgium, 2001.
[72]
Galetto, F., Quality and Control Carts: Managerial assessment during Product Development and Production Process, AT&T (Society of Automotive Engineers), Barcelona, 2001.
[73]
Galetto, F., Quality QFD and control charts: a managerial assessment during the product development process, Congresso ATA, Firenze, 2001.
[74]
Galetto, F., Business excellence Quality and Control Charts, 7th TQM Conf., Verona, 2002.
[75]
Galetto, F., Fuzzy Logic and Control Charts, 3rd ICME 2002 Conference, Ischia, 2002.
[76]
Galetto, F., Quality education on Quality for future managers, 5th World Congr. on Engineering Education of NOT, Varsavia, 2002.
[77]
Galetto, F., Analysis of "new" control charts for Quality assessment, 5th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Lisbon, Portugal, 2002.
[78]
Galetto, F., Quality decisions and ISO 9000:2000 Principles, 6th AMST 99, Udine, 2002.
[79]
Galetto, F., Quality and “quality magazines”, 6th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Oviedo, Spain, 2003.
[80]
Galetto F., G. Pistone, M. P. Rogantin, Confounding revisited with commutative computational algebra, Journal of statistical planning and inference,, 2003.
[81]
Galetto, F., "Six Sigma Approach" and Testing, ICEM12 –12th Intern. Conf. on Experimental Mechanics, Bari Politecnico, 2004.
[82]
Galetto, F., Reliability analysis in product development, AMST 2005, Udine, 2005.
[83]
Galetto, F., Statistics for Quality and “quality magazines”, 5th ENBIS, Newcastle, 2005.
[84]
Galetto, F., Service Quality: Fuzzy Logic and Yager Method; a scientific analysis, IFIP TC 7, Politecnico di Torino, 2005.
[85]
Galetto, F., Quality and “Statistics Packages”, 8th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Palermo, 2005.
[86]
Galetto, F., Quality Education and “quality papers”, IPSI 2006, Marbella, 2006.
[87]
Galetto, F., Fuzzy Logic and Quality Control: a scientific analysis, IPSI 2006, Amalfi, 2006.
[88]
Galetto, F., Quality Education versus "Peer Review", IPSI 2006, Montenegro, 2006.
[89]
Galetto, F., Does "Peer Review" assure Quality of papers and Education?, 8th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Paisley, Scotland, 2006.
[90]
Galetto, F., Quality Education versus "Peer Review", IPSI 2006, Montenegro, 2006.
[91]
Galetto, F., A must: Quality of teaching, IPSI 2006, Portofino, 2006.
[92]
Galetto, F., The Pentalogy, VIPSI, Belgrado, 2009.
[93]
Galetto, F., The Pentalogy Beyond, 9th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Verona, 2010.
[94]
Galetto, F., Six Sigma: help or hoax for Quality?, 11th Conf. on TQM for HEI, Israel, 2012.
[95]
Galetto, F., Bibiliometrics: Help or Hoax for Quality?, UJER 2(4),, DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2014.020404, 2014.
[96]
Galetto, F., Riemann Hypothesis Proved, Academia Arena 6(12):19-22, ISSN 1553-992X, 2014.
[97]
Galetto, F., Hope for the Future: Overcoming the DEEP Ignorance on the CI (Confidence Intervals) and on the DOE (Design of Experiments, Science J. Applied Mathematics and Statistics. Vol. 3, No. 3, pp. 70-95, doi: 10.11648/j.sjams.20150303.12, 2015.
[98]
Galetto, F., Management Versus Science: Peer-Reviewers do not Know the Subject They Have to Analyse, Journal of Investment and Management. Vol. 4, No. 6, pp. 319-329, doi: 10.11648/j.jim.20150406.15, 2015.
[99]
Galetto, F., The first step to Science Innovation: Down to the Basics., Journal of Investment and Management. Vol. 4, No. 6, pp. 319-329, doi: 10.11648/j.jim.20150406.15, 2015.
[100]
Galetto, F., AFFIDABILITÀ vol. 1 Teoria e Metodi di calcolo, CLEUP editore, Padova, 81, 84, 87, 94.
[101]
Galetto, F., AFFIDABILITÀ vol. 2 Prove di affidabilità: distribuzione incognita, distribuzione esponenziale, CLEUP editore, Padova, 82, 85, 94.
[102]
Galetto, F., Qualità. Alcuni metodi statistici da Manager, CUSL, 1995/7/9.
[103]
Galetto, F., Gestione Manageriale della Affidabilità. CLUT, Torino.
[104]
Galetto, F., Manutenzione e Affidabilità. CLUT, Torino.
[105]
Galetto, F., 2016, Reliability and Maintenance, Scientific Methods, Practical Approach, Vol-1, www.morebooks.de.
[106]
Galetto, F., 2016, Reliability and Maintenance, Scientific Methods, Practical Approach, Vol-2, www.morebooks.de.
[107]
Galetto, F., 2016, Design Of Experiments and Decisions, Scientific Methods, Practscal Approach, www.morebooks.de.
[108]
Galetto, F., 2017, The Six Sigma HOAX versus the versus the Golden Integral Quality Approach LEGACY, www.morebooks.de.
[109]
Galetto, F., Papers and Documents in the Academia.edu, 2015-2017.
[110]
Galetto, F., Several Papers and Documents in the Research Gate Database, 2014 (the cases are in § 5 a.-gg.).
Browse journals by subject